The Impact of Covid-19 on Families of Children with Developmental Disabilities in Canada: A Systematic Review on Parental Stress and Coping Strategies

Research Article | DOI: https://doi.org/10.31579/2690-4861/623

The Impact of Covid-19 on Families of Children with Developmental Disabilities in Canada: A Systematic Review on Parental Stress and Coping Strategies

  • Chang Su 1*
  • Amanda Chen 2

1Associate Professor, Department of Psychology, Faculty of Science, Brandon University, Brandon Manitoba, Canada. 

2Arthur Labat School of Nursing, Western University, London, Canada.

*Corresponding Author: Chang Su, Department of Psychology, Faculty of Science, Brandon University, Manitoba, Canada. Email: [email protected],

Citation: Chang Su, Amanda Chen (2024). The Impact of Covid-19 on Families of Children with Developmental Disabilities in Canada: A Systematic Review on Parental Stress and Coping Strategies. International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews, 21(1). DOI:10.31579/2690-4861/623

Copyright: © 2024, Chang Su and Amanda Chen. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Received: 22 November 2024 | Accepted: 25 December 2024 | Published: 31 December 2024

Keywords: developmental disabilities; systematic review; caregiver; stress; coping strategy

Abstract

Background/Aim: Quarantine restrictions and the suspension of in-person learning have posed significant challenges and stress for parents while negatively affecting children’s behavioural, social, and emotional development. Parents of children with developmental disabilities (DDs) face additional difficulties across various of developmental domains and often experience heightened strain, low mood, mental health-related symptoms, and distress. During COVID-19, parents of children DDs have reported higher levels of parental stress, anxiety, along with lower levels of psychological well-being than those of children without DDs. The aim of this systematic review was to provide a comprehensive perspective through reviewing the existing literature to explore the parental stress encountered by parents of children with DDs due to COVID-19, and their coping strategies they employed for supporting their children in adapting to ongoing learning activities and addressing social-emotional needs during the COVID-19 crisis.

Materials/Methods: A systematic extensive search was conducted in several databases including PubMed, CINAHL, PsycINFO, ERIC, Google Scholar, and Google internet in English were used for the keywords search (i.e., parental/family stress/challenges, parents/caregivers, child/children with DDs, autism, ADHD, Neurodevelopmental Disorders, coping, strategies, COVID-19, pandemic, Canada), and thirty-one articles (including peer reviewed published articles and graduate school theses (between 2020 and 2024)) were included in the review based on inclusion and exclusion criteria. Two reviewers will independently screen the literature and extract data. A thematic analysis involves reading through the findings and themes was generated and confirmed. Article summaries were charted. 

Results: Themes of parental stressors were identified include disruptions to daily routines and increased workloads, difficulties in managing children’s emotional and behavioural problems leading to parental frustration, limited access to resources and various forms of support, experiences of mental health problems, experiences of social isolation, and reduced self-efficacy. Coping strategies highlighted include fostering family-teacher partnerships and psychological interventions are essential, creating a structured daily schedule, providing support and utilizing new technologies for online learning, promoting self-efficacy and resilience, and ensuring access to protective measures.

Discussion: Parents of children with DDs need specific attention and resiliency to face these challenges, family-friendly policies can help parents have a more balanced and adaptable life during the pandemic. More social support from family, friends, school, and the broader community are needed for parents of children with DDs. 

Conclusions: Parent stress increased significantly during COVID-19 pandemic when raising children with DDs due to pandemic lockdown measures. The systematic review outlined sources of stress and summarized supportive coping strategies. Our findings suggest that public health interventions should focus on addressing specific stressors and promoting effective coping strategies while considering the unique needs of these families to mitigate the impacts of pandemic.

Introduction

COVID-19 pandemic emerged as a major global crisis, posing a significant threat to public health, and profoundly disrupting daily routines, work, education and social connections worldwide [1,2,3] Quarantine measures, including social distancing, and lockdowns, created unprecedented challenges. These included the closure or suspension of health and social services, schools, and daycares centers. The cessation of in-person learning promoted a swift transition to remote education, significantly altering most in-person social, educational and therapeutic programs [4,1,5,6,7,8] increasing stress levels [9], which let to negative mental health consequences, including psychological distress, depression, and anxiety among parents and caregivers. [10,11,12,13,14,15]. Additionally, children with disabilities experienced significant disruptions affecting their behavioral, social, and emotional development [16,17,18,19,20,21].

Those with developmental disabilities (DDs), particularly children, faced heightened infection risks and struggled to access therapies, maintain physical distancing, and adapt to routine changes [22,23]. Research highlights those individuals with autism faced additional challenges, particularly in accessing essential therapies and coping with disruptions in their daily lives [24]. The global public health emergency significantly heightened mental health risks for families of children with DDs [13,25,26]. Parents of children with DDs faced economic challenges, social marginalization, and elevated stress due to the abrupt disruptions in their routines [27,28,29,21].  Stressors included fears of infection, financial losses, employment insecurity, stigma, and difficulties accessing food, medication, and essential services such as transition to telehealth [1,30,16,31,32,33].

Parental stress, defined as “a state which arises from an actual or perceived demand capability imbalance in the parent’s functioning, which is characterized by a multidimensional demand for adjustment or adaptive behavior” [34, pg. 9]. Factors such as limited access to protection materials, inaccessible information, service closures, and   disrupted routines, including poor sleep, reduced exercise, and lower diet quality have been shown to negatively affect parental well-being [27,35,29, 36,37,35,29,36,37,33]. Research shows that parents of children with DDs are at a significantly higher risk of depression or other mental health challenges compared to parents of typically developing children in Canada [38,39,40,41,42]. In Canada, one in 16 children is diagnosed with a DD, such as autism, cerebral palsy, ADHD, or metabolic-genetic disorders, which affect cognitive, language motor, and behavioural development [43].

Recent studies indicated that Canadian parents of children with DDs faced heightened concerns and challenges during COVID-19. Key challenges included school closure, shift to remote learning for the educational transitions, concerns about academic success, online safety, lack of accessible information and supports, and disruptions of diagnostic services [1,44,45,35,28,29,46,16], longtime waiting list for children’s assessment, managing increased screen time on electronic devices, loneliness due to lack of social connections and being isolated, and reduced physical activity due to insufficient play spaces [1,44,45,28, 46,16,51], eating junk food [45], and struggles with remote learning, nearly half expressing concerns in academic remote learning [45,28]. Especially, racialized families of children with DDs faced different barriers such as inadequate government funding, inaccessible services, long wait times mental health care, systemic racism, limited school support, inadequate school support, and poor interprofessional collaboration [45,46]. Parents also reported concerns about their children’s physical and mental health, caregiver fatigue and exhaustion elevated stress, and anxiety levels [44,45,35,47,29,16,15],   lack of social support, worsened financial security, and loss the essential services [35,47,16], limited socialization for children [44,45,47,48,49], difficulties to manage children’s behaviours [35,28,46,48,16,49,50], and reduced patience, poor and harsh parenting behaviours, admitted to scolding, or yelling at their children [50]. A recent study [49] used mixed methods found that caregivers of children with disabilities and developmental delays had lower scores in accessing resources and social support, and lower self-care than ones of children without developmental delays in the quantitative study, and also the qualitative results showed that caregivers identified negative impacts from COVID-19, including many disruptions in children’s regular daily routine and structures, mental health problems, increased financial burdens, limited access to support services, and interventions.

Researchers emphasized the need for practical coping strategies and sufficient support to help families of children with DDs manage challenges and deal with the burden of increased care demands during COVID-19 in Canada [1,29,50]. Many parents actively sought available resources, including school and community tailoring services, ensure continuity of care, rehab, primary care, acute care, mental health support, various therapies and educational assistance, and online social programs and virtual platforms, to help their children to avoid social isolation and maintain a sense of connection [1,47,48,51,52,53]. Parents reported keeping safe during pandemic were essential, educating children with DDs to follow the appropriate requests and measures to avoid the infection from COVID-19 virus [16,49].

Parents and caregivers reported helping their children participate in daily family routines, understand children’s needs [48], incorporating regular times for learning, meals, play activities and relaxation time with the family members. They shared activities provided opportunities for communication and strengthened families’ cohesion [44,48,16]. Parents created some physical activities, organized children’s leisure activities, and arranging virtual meetups with relatives and friends to support their social connections and overall well-being. Moreover, parents used positive reinforcement strategies to provide feedback to children with DDs. This approach encouraged active learning and maintained their children’s enthusiasm for exploration, avoiding the stress and overwhelm often associated with setting overly ambitious goals [44,54,55]. Additionally, coping strategies for autistic individuals and their families during the COVID-19 in Canada emphasized the importance of fostering resilience, self-efficacy, acceptance, and positive family function [1,16, 56,51].

Given COVID-19 pandemic presented significant negative impacts on families of children with DDs in Canada, it is important to support their mental health and well-being of parents with children with DDs to deeply understand their challenges and effective coping strategies during and after pandemic. This systematic review aimed to synthesize findings from research on challenges and copings of families of children with DDs, incorporating commentary, brief report, scoping review, quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-method studies provide a comprehensive perspective to examine existing literature on 1) parental stress as the unique challenges faced by caregivers of children with DDs during COVID-19 and 2) their coping strategies in Canada during pandemic for providing support and assisting their children with DDs in adapting to the continued learning activities and social-emotional needs during or after COVID-19 crisis and to consolidate parenting interventions.

Methods

A systematic review of the extensive search was conducted, including search strategies, eligibility criteria, what data was extracted from the selected research articles, and what the variables of interest were. Online databases (PsycINFO, CINAHL, PubMed, MEDLINE, EBSCOhost, ERIC, and Google Scholar), the internet (Google) from January 2020 to June 2022 in English were used for the keywords search (i.e., “parental/caregiver/family stress, not (before 2020)”, AND “coping, strategies for parents of child/children (≤12 years old) with developmental disabilities” OR “autism, or ADHD, or neurodevelopmental disorders”, AND “COVID-19/coronavirus/pandemic” AND “Canada”). The following eligibility criteria for inclusion were used to select articles for this study: (1) written in English; (2) published after 2020; (3) were full-text articles; (4) identified stressors and coping strategies for parents/caregivers/families of children with DDs (5) Canada. Articles not relevant to the research aims were all excluded from this study. A second round of searches were in September and November 14th of 2024 to identify new empirical studies that were published after the original search time period. Exclusion criteria included conference abstracts, published in other languages, guidelines, and syllabus materials. Thirty-one articles (including peer reviewed journal articles, graduate school theses (between 2020 and 2024)) were included in the review based on inclusion and exclusion criteria (see Figure 1).

Figure 1: Flow-chart depicting the search strategy in the review.

Two reviewers independently screened the title, abstracts, findings of the articles, read the full texts to assess eligibility and determine if the selected articles met the inclusion criteria, and extracted information from each article and categorized themes related to the impact of COVID-19 on parental stress and coping strategies during the pandemic. Any disagreements regarding the content themes were solved through discussions.  A thematic analysis involves reading through the findings and themes was generated and confirmed. The following data items were extracted for each study, including the authors’ name, year of publication, study design, aim of article, main findings, sample characteristics, and method of data collection. Article summaries were organized in a chart format (see Table 1). 

No

Author(s)

/Date published

TitleJournalType of crew of the participants

Categories

Peer-reviewed

Qualitative

Report

Editorial

Aim of articleMain findings
1Ameis, S.H., Lai, M.C., Mulsant, B.H., Szatmari, P. (2020).Coping, fostering resilience, and driving care innovation for autistic people and their families during the COVID-19 pandemic and beyond.

Molecular Autism

 

Autism

Commentary

 

To foster coping strategies and enhance resilience not only for both individual with autism and their family, but also for the autism-friendly changes in healthcare, social systems, and

the broader socio-ecological

Regular care systems are not sufficient to meet the needs of the autism communities since people have shifted to online school and increased use of remote delivery of healthcare and autism supports during COVID-19. Using more telehealth platforms had a positive impact on both care and research and could help to address key priorities for the autism communities.
2Arim, R., Findlay, L., Kohen, D. (2023)The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on Canadian families of children with disabilities.Gender, Diversity and Inclusion Statistics Hub84% children with cognitive, behavioural, and emotional problems (such as ADHD).ReportThe purpose of this report was to examine differences in experiences between families of children with and without disabilities during the COVID‑19 pandemic as reported by parents or guardians of children aged 0 to 14 yearsCrowdsourcing participants’ various concerns for their family were similar between parents of children with and without disabilities, a higher proportion of parents of children with disabilities were very or extremely concerned for their children’s amount of screen time, loneliness or isolation, general mental health, school year and academic success.
3Buchanan, T., Phung, N., Hammoud, M., Kjartanson, K., & Friesen, A. (2024).Parental concerns during the COVID-19 pandemic: Intersections for racialized mothers of children with             disabilities.Journal of Child and Family StudiesChildren with disabilities (including special needs)Quantitative studyTo examine how parenting as a racialized mother who has a child with a disability (also including ASD) impacted concerns for children and family during the pandemic; and to examine how these experiences depend upon the family life stage of these mothers.This study emphasizes the importance of intersectional considerations during the early pandemic relating to parenting for racialized mothers of children with disabilities. Parents with only preschool children were less concerned for children but reported slightly higher levels of family concerns.
4Cardy, R.E., Dupuis, A., Anagnostou, E., Ziolkowski, J., Biddiss, E.A., Monga, S., Brian, J., Penner, M., & Kushki, A. (2021)Characterizing changes in screen time during the COVID-19 pandemic school closures in Canada and its perceived impact on children with autism spectrum disorder.Front PsychiatryChildren with autism spectrum disorder.Quantitative studyTo characterize the change in screen time during COVID-19 school closures for children with ASD, and (2) examine the parent perceived impact of screen time on mental health and quality of life of children and their families.Compared to the community sample, the ASD group had a significantly higher screen time use before and during the COVID-19 pandemic school closures. Gender was a significant predictor of parent perceived mental health and quality of life, with male gender associated with a higher likelihood of negative impact of quality of life and mental health. Parents’ most frequently endorsed emotions toward screen time were guilt, frustration, and worry.
5Colucci, L., Smith, J. A., & Browne, D. T. (2023).Parenting and pandemic pressures:                Examining nuances in parent, child, and family well-being concerns during COVID-19 in a Canadian Sample. Frontiers in EpidemiologyFrontiers in EpidemiologyChildren and some children with disabilities (e.g. autism)Quantitative study

To know about the areas of family life parents are most concerned about and how these worries relate to well-being across the family system.

 

Higher child and family concerns were reported by parents who had not attended university, those who had experienced employment loss or reduced hours, and families with all adults working outside the home. Parents of children with a disability reported higher concerns across all three domains: child, parenting, and family psychosocial well-being.
6Currie, G., Finlay, B., Seth, A., Roth, C., Elsabbagh, M., Hudon, A., … Zwicker, J. (2022).

Mental health challenges during COVID-19: perspectives from parents with children with neurodevelopmental disabilities.

 

International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-Being

 

Children with neurodevelopmental disabilities (NDDs)Qualitative designTo understand the impacts of these public health measures and restrictions on mental health from the perspective of parents with children with NDDs to inform pathways for public health policies responsive to the needs of this population.Generic policy measures contributed to many gaps in families’ social support systems and contributed to mental health challenges for children and their parents. Four themes emerged: 1) lack of social networks and activities, 2) lack of access to health and social supports, 3) tension in the family unit, and 4) impact on mental health for children and their parents.
7Currie, G., Materula, D., Gall, N., Lachuk, G., Richard, C., Yohemas, M., Dewan, T., Gibbard, W.B., & Zwicker, J.     (2023)Care coordination of children with neurodevelopmental disabilities and medical complexity during the COVID‐19 pandemic: Caregiver experiences.Child: Care, Health and DevelopmentChildren with neurodevelopmental disabilitiesA qualitative descriptive designTo examine the implications of pandemic restrictions on care coordination from caregiver perspectives. These experiences can inform emergency preparedness planning and recovery strategies.

Two themes emerged: (1) disruptions to care coordination from initial COVID-19 restrictions leading to lack of access to supports and services, increasing level of need, and impacts of disruption for caregivers and children; and (2) adaptation and responsiveness to COVID-19 restrictions by advocating for families and managing uncertainties.

 

8

 

Deotto, A.,   Fabiano, F. G., Chung, Y. T. B.,  Wade, L. S.,  Anagnostou, E.,  Crosbie, j.,  Kelley, E.,   Nicolson, R.,   Andrade, F. B.,   Miller, P. S.,  Williams, S. T. (2023)Stepping up to COVID-19: A clinical trial of a telepsychology positive parenting program targeting behavior problems in children with neurological risk.Journal of Pediatric Psychology

children with neurological risk

 

 

 

Quantitative studyTo evaluate the feasibility, acceptability, and preliminary efficacy of a stepped-care parenting program implemented during COVID-19 among families of behaviorally at-risk children with neurological or neurodevelopmental disorders aged 3–9 years.Parents reported high acceptability, reflected in themes surrounding accessibility, comprehension, effectiveness, and targeted care. Positive parenting skill increases were documented, and robust improvement in child behavior problems was apparent upon Step 3 completion. Stepped care was as effective as traditional delivery, while improving consent and completion rates within a pandemic context.
9Filler T, Benipal PK, Minhas RS, Suleman S. (2022).Exploring the impact of COVID-19 on            families of children with developmental disabilities: A community-based formative study.

Paediatric Child Health

 

children with developmental disabilitiesQualitative study

This qualitative study was to identify the experiences of families of children with DD during the COVID-19 pandemic.

 

Families reported difficulty adhering to public health measures leading to isolation and increased parental stress; restricted access to in-person services worsened behaviour and development; and worsened household financial security in already marginalized families.   Public health restrictions have impaired the daily lives of these families of children with DDs.
10Friesen, K. A., Weiss, J. A., Howe, S. J., Kerns, C. M., & McMorris, C. A. (2022).Mental             health and resilient coping in caregivers of autistic individuals during the COVID-19             pandemic: findings from the families facing COVID study.

Journal of autism and             developmental disorders

 

AutismQuantitative study

To characterize caregiver stress, anxiety, and resilient coping during COVID-19 and investigated the impact of COVID-19 disruptions, demographic variables, and resilient coping on

mental health.

Most of the caregivers reported some degree of disruption associated with COVID-19, and more than half reported moderate levels of stress and high anxiety. Resilient coping did not emerge as a moderator between COVID-19 disruptions and caregiver mental health, but instead had a direct effect on outcomes.
11Gonzalez, M., Zeidan, J., Lai, J. et al. (2022).Socio-demographic disparities in receipt of            clinical health care services during the COVID-19 pandemic for Canadian children with             disability.

BMC Health Service Research

 

 

children with developmental disabilities and delaysQuantitative studyTo need for tailoring services for families of children with disabilities, particularly low socioeconomic status families, to ensure continuity of care during public health emergencies.The needs for tailoring services for families of children with disabilities are essential, particularly low socioeconomic status families, to ensure continuity of care during public health emergencies. Being a single parent, having low educational attainment, having low income, working less than full time, as well as male gender and older age of the child with disability were factors associated with decreased likelihood of receiving services.
12Gowans, L., Ritchie, T., Rogers, M. A., Jiang, Y., Climie, E. A., Mah, J. W. T., Corkum, P., Krause, A., & Parvanova, M. (2024).

The association between the impact of covid-19 and internalizing problems among children and adolescents with ADHD: The moderating role of parental anxiety.

 

Child Psychiatry and Human Development.Children and adolescents with ADHD

Quantitative

study

To assess whether the impact of COVID-19 was associated with internalizing problems in children and adolescents with ADHD during pandemic, and whether parental anxiety moderated this relationship over time.The results indicated that the impact of COVID-19 on children at T1 (Spring 2021) was a unique predictor of child internalizing problems at T1 but not at T2 (Fall/Winter 2022). While parental anxiety did not moderate this association cross-sectionally, it was a significant moderator longitudinally. More specifically, low parental anxiety at T1 positively moderated the association between the COVID-19 impact on children at T1 and child internalizing problems at T2.
13Jacques, C., Saulnier, G., Éthier, A., & Soulières, I. (2021).Experience of autistic children and
their families during the pandemic: from distress to coping strategies.
Journal Autism Development DisorderAutistic childrenMixed methods design (both quantitative and qualitative study)To need to consider the child’s autistic characteristics and interests to implement emergency accommodations and services.Parents reported the concerns about their child with DDs and difficulties managing their child’s behaviors before and during pandemic were significantly associated. Parents identified maintaining social relationships and implementing appropriate interventions to their child’s characteristics as facilitators during the pandemic.
14Katalifos, A. (2023).

Alignment of Canada’s COVID-19 policy response with barriers and

facilitators for coping reported by caregivers of children and youth with developmental disabilities, delays and disorders.

ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global

 

Children with

developmental delays, disorders, and

disabilities (DDDs)

Qualitative studyThe aim was increasing awareness, compiling data, proving guidance for policy and programming, and engaging international-level partners on understanding and improving the conditions of children and youth with disabilities around the globe.Prioritizing needs of families of youths with DDDs during a public health emergency can significantly impact their experiences and mental health.   Barriers to coping at the individual level were family mental health complications, concerns about regression of the child’s condition, along with challenges involving the child’s online schooling, insufficient play spaces, and managing physical health in quarantine. Environmental barrier included the worsening of families’ finances, loss of public services, and experiencing stigma.
15Kingsbury, M., Arim, R., & Findlay, L. (2023).Parenting concerns during the COVID-19               pandemic: Results from a Canadian crowdsource sample.

Journal of Family Issues

 

Family with children with disabilityQuantitative studyTo examine parents’ concerns regarding their own parenting behaviour during the pandemic and to explore the characteristics of families who may be particularly vulnerable to parenting concerns, and to identify families (e.g., parents with disabilities) that may be more at risk of increased parenting concerns during the pandemicMany parents were very or extremely concerned about managing child behaviour and having less patience with, scolding, or yelling at their children.
16Lamptey, D., McIsaac, D.., MacQuarrie, M., Cummings, R., Rossiter, D. M., Janus, M., & Turner, J. (2024).

Relationship between childhood disability or developmental delay and COVID-19 Pandemic Impacts on Families across the Canadian Maritime Provinces

 

Journal of Child and Family Studies

 

childhood disability or developmental delayMixed methods design (both quantitative and qualitative study)To examine the early impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on family environments that influenced early childhood development of children with disability and developmental delays and health in the Maritime provinces of CanadaThe study findings indicate that the early impacts of the pandemic on family environments that influenced early childhood development and health of children with disabilities or developmental delays were mixed and context specific. The study findings inform the development of context-specific policies and programs to adequately support families of children with disabilities or developmental delays in public health crises similar to the pandemic.
17Laughlin, E.  (2022)Leisure as a Coping Resource for Parent Caregivers of Children Living with AutismHonor thesis, Broke UniversityChildren living with autismQualitative studyTo explore the lived experiences of life challenges and leisure as a stress coping resources among parent caregiver of children living with autism.These parent’s caregivers face a number of barriers related to their leisure participation in four areas: (a) caregiving responsibilities and demands, (b) COVID-19 related barriers (c) time-related barrier and (d) interpersonal barrier. The findings also revealed that leisure was used as a stress-coping resource in four ways: (1) rejuvenation through leisure, (2) mood enhancement through leisure, (3) distance from stressors through leisure, and (4) social experiences through leisure.
18Lee, V., Albaum, C., Tablon Modica, P., Ahmad, F., Gorter, J.W., Khanlou, N., McMorris, C., Lai, J.,                Harrison, C., Hedley, T., Johnston, P., Putterman, C., Spoelstra, M., & Weiss, J.A. (2021).The impact of COVID-19 on the mental health and wellbeing of caregivers of autistic                 children and youth: A scoping review.

Autism Research

 

 

Autism

A scoping

review

To identify pandemic related demands experienced and coping strategies by caregivers and families of autistic children and youth.Our findings suggest a number of demands have increased caregivers’ risk to mental health challenges, and their potential impact on family wellbeing. Ongoing development of evidence-based supports of all families of autistic children and youth are needed.
19MacSorley, C. A. (2022).The lived experience of parental stress of fathers of a child with autism spectrum disorder.

A Thesis of Master of Social Work. University of Regina

 

AutismQualitative studyTo expand the current understanding of father parental stress through an interpretive phenomenological analysis of fathers of children with autism spectrum disorder’s lived experience.Five superordinate themes were identified, including Covid-19 pandemic, isolation, self-efficacy, stressors, and coping. Participants highlighted the breakdown of their limited supports during the global pandemic, and the sense of loss, isolation, and frustration created. Participants also identified negative perceptions of their self-efficacy and lack of dedicated supports for fathers.
20Majnemer, A., McGrath, J. P., Baumbusch,J., Camden,C., Fallon, B., Lunsky, Y., Steven P. Miller, S. P., Sansone, G., Stainton, T., Sumarah, J, Thomson, J., & Zwicker, J. (2021).Time to be counted: COVID-19 and intellectual and developmental disabilities-an RSC Policy Briefing.

FACETS

 

Intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDDs)Policy Briefing reportTo examine the risks and recommendations of mental health issues due to COVID-19 pandemic for persons with IDDs.

Not only do people with IDD have a greater risk of severe complications and death from the virus as shown in large-scale studies, but they also face significant short- and long-term consequences of COVID-related public

health measures on their mental health and well-being.

21

Myers, M. (2021)

 

 

The experiences of co-parents raising children with autism spectrum disorders during the COVID-19 pandemic.Master Degree Thesis in University of Guelph,Children with autism spectrum disordersMixed methods design (both quantitative and qualitative study)To explore the experiences of caregivers coparenting a child with ASD during the COVID-19 pandemic. Caregivers have an essential part in maintaining the family system. Children with ASD may be particularly vulnerable to the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, including social isolation, disruptions to structure and routine and lack of therapies and schooling available, especially considering need for routine and sameness are characteristics of ASD.The main themes which emerged from the data included caregiver’s concerns regarding their own wellbeing due to increased caregiver demands and confinement related stressors, their child’s adjustment to a lack of structure and routine, relational functioning due to negotiating time together, and family resilience in the face of adversity. An illustration of the centrality of the co-parenting relationship in supporting child adjustment is provided.
22

Osman L, & Whitley J.

(2024)

Parent perceptions of social well-being in children with special educational needs during COVID-19: A mixed-methods analysis.

 

 

Child Care HealthChildren with special educational needsQuantitative and qualitative studyTo analyse impacts of these changes on social well-being, with limited studies placing an emphasis on the experiences of students with special educational needs (SENs). This article focusses on parent perspectives regarding impacts of school closures on social well-being in Canadian children with SENs.The majority of parents expressed concern for their child's social well-being during the Spring 2020 school closures, with increased concerns for younger children. According to parents, children experienced communication barriers to peer interaction and many experienced emotional difficulties as a result. Technology was described as critical for some in maintaining social connections. Parents raised concerns about the impact of limited peer interaction on broader social skill development, in the short and long term.
23Pizzo,  A., Keys E, Corkum P.  (2023)Parental perceptions of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the sleep of children with neurodevelopmental Disorders.

Journal Pediatric Health Care.

 

Children with neurodevelopmental Disorders.

Quantitative

study

To determine and describe the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic; To identify and describe contributing factors.

 

Most parents (66%) reported the pandemic did not worsen their child's sleep, 30% stated their child's sleep had worsened, and 4% reported an improvement. Stress and anxiety about the pandemic, disrupted routines, and increased screen time were common parent-identified contributing factors.
24

Schmidt, M. & Bronw, M. Š.I. (2023)

 

Parents helping a child with disability learn at home during COVID-19: Experiences from Slovenia and Canada

 

Journal of Policy and Practice in Intellectual Disabilities

 

Canadian child with disability (ASD, ADHD, some in ASD learning programs); Slovenian sample with special education needs (ASD, ADHD)Mixed methods design (both quantitative and qualitative study)The specific research questions were: (1) Did the Slovenian and Canadian parents differ in their perceived workload—assisting their children with remote learning? (2) Did the Slovenian and Canadian parents differ according to the support and resources received from schools and teachers? and (3) Did the Slovenian and Canadian parents differ according to their satisfaction with home-schooling their children with SEN and disabilities?Parents in both countries (Slovenia and Canada) identified several specific advantages and disadvantages to learning remotely from home. The Slovenian children spent more hours per day at their lessons and attended more lessons than the Canadian children.
25Seth, Ash et al. (2022).Impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic: Pan-Canadian perspectives from parents and caregivers of youth with neurodevelopmental disabilities.

Journal of Pediatric Health Care

 

 

Qualitative studyChildren and youth with neurodevelopmental disabilitiesTo understand the experiences and perspectives of parents and caregivers of youth with NDD across Canada in accessing services and their mental health needs during the COVID-19 pandemic; To explore the impacts of COVID-19 on parents, caregivers, and youth with NDD and identified recommendations for disability-inclusive policy planning and development.The results enabled us to understand the impact of service disruptions in significant areas of life, including health, education, employment, and risk mitigation.
26Smile, S.C. (2020).Supporting children with autism spectrum disorder in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Canadian Medical Association Journal

 

AutismCommentary (letter)To address the mental distress of autistic children and children who are quarantined, to emphasis on designing diverse, sociocultural appropriate programs to address mental distress and provide mental health care and psychosocial supports

The consequences of a pandemic and the measures decrease transmission of coronavirus COVID-19, which have affected children and youth with autism spectrum disorder

and their families, including siblings. parental anxiety around job loss, economic uncertainty, lack of access to health care facilities and treatment centres, and extension of waitlists for early intervention programs

27Swansburg, R., Hai, T., MacMaster, F.P., & Lemay, J.F. (2021).Impact of COVID-19 on lifestyle habits and mental health symptoms in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder in Canada.Paediatric Child Health.Children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorderQuantitative studyTo investigate the impact of COVID-19 on lifestyle habits and mental health symptoms in paediatric attention-deficit/ hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in Canada.17.4% and 14.1% of children met criteria for moderately severe to severe depression and anxiety symptoms respectively. Children met SNAP-IV cut-off scores for inattention, hyperactivity/ impulsivity, and oppositional defiant disorder behaviours. Caregivers reported changes in sleep, eating, exercise, and screen use in their ADHD child, greatly impacting youth. The COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in less healthy lifestyle habits and increased mental health symptoms in Canadian children with ADHD.
28Wendel, M., Ritchie, T., Rogers, M. A., Ogg, J. A., Santuzzi, A. M., Shelleby, E. C., & Menter, K. (2020).The association between child ADHD symptoms and changes in parental involvement in kindergarten children’s learning during COVID-19School Psychology ReviewChild with ADHD symptomsLongitudinal research

To examine the changes to parent and child behavior due to COVID-19 among 4- and 5-year-old children and their parents. Changes in attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) symptoms and levels of parental involvement in children’s learning were examined. ADHD symptoms were also examined as a moderator of changes in parent involvement.

 

The mean levels of ADHD symptoms fell at the midpoint between never  (1) and sometimes (2). To gain insight into the frequency of clinical levels of ADHD symptoms, we also examined the number of child participants at each time point who had parent-rated ADHD symptoms above the 90th percentile. Correlations between key variables in the spring showed that parent beliefs were positively associated with each other. Home-based involvement was also associated with all parental involvement beliefs. Child levels of inattention showed a significant and negative association with parental self-efficacy and knowledge and skills. Child levels of hyperactivity/impulsivity were negatively associated with all parental involvement beliefs.
29Williams, T.S., Burek, B., Deotto, A., Ford, M.K., Green, R., & Wade, S.L. (2022)Pandemic perils and promise: Implementation of a virtual parenting intervention during COVID-19 among children with early neurological conditions.Developmental Neurorehabilitation.Children with early neurological conditions.Mixed methods design (both quantitative and qualitative study)To examine feasibility, acceptability, and preliminary efficacy of a tele-psychological positive parenting interventionParents reported strong therapeutic alliance and programme acceptability with barriers due to competing time demands. Therapists reported high acceptability but perceived parental burnout. Parenting confidence, and child behavior improved following the intervention.
30Williams, T. S., Deotto, A., Roberts, S. D., Ford, M. K., Désiré, N., & Cunningham, S. (2021).COVID-19 mental health impact among children with early brain injury and associated conditions.

Child Neuropsychology

 

Children with early brain injury and associated

conditions

Mixed methods design (both quantitative and qualitative study)To describe the mental health impact of COVID-19 among a clinical research sample of parents with children diagnosed with early brain injury and/or associated conditions impacting brain development; To examine risk factors for elevated mental health impact by child factors including age, sex, brain injury severity, intellectual/global functioning, and comorbid ADHD and intellectual diagnoses, as well as salient psychosocial contextual factors.Over 40% of parents described moderate to extreme influence of COVID-19 on their child’s mental health. Common child stressors reported included restrictions on leaving the home and social isolation. Among parents, the most common stress reported was caring for their child’s education and daily activities. Some COVID-19 positives were identified, namely increased quality family time. Findings reflect the significant pandemic mental health impact.
31Winfield, A., Sugar, C., & Fenesi, B. (2023)

The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the

mental health of families dealing with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder.

PLoS ONE 18(3): e0283227.

 

Children with ADHDQualitative studyTo examine 1) the unique ways that the COVID-19 pandemic affected their mental health and 2) the specific barriers these families faced to maintaining optimal mental wellbeing.Content analysis revealed that the most frequently identified mental health effects for families were increased child anxiety and disconnectedness, as well as deteriorating parental mental health. The most frequently identified barriers to maintaining optimal mental wellbeing were lack of routine, lack of social interaction and social supports, and uncertainty and fear.

Table 1: Parental stress and coping strategies based on characteristics of children

Results

The systematic review design was used in this literature study.

Disruptions to daily routines, and increased workloads.

In March and April 2020, Canada implemented schools and daycare closures, among other measures, to prevent the spread of Covid-19. These shutdowns negatively impacted student learning and socializations. Parents struggled with online learning, faced challenges keeping up with school assignments, and expressed heightened concerns about the future academic developments of children with DDs [1,44,45,35,28,29,46,48, 16,50,53,54,55]. A scoping review [15] on mental health and well-being of autistic children and youth highlighted several challenges faced by parents and caregivers, including school, campus program, and service closures resulted in loss of essential services, which increased unpredictability [35,44,47,16,48,50,54]. Additionally, parents were required to take on extra roles, such as managing children’s daily schedules while continuing their own work, leading to increased workloads. Many were overwhelmed by the demands of caring for their children without the daily support of specialists, coupled with other obligations and responsibilities [47,16,54]. 

Difficulties in managing children’s emotional and behavioural problems leading to parental frustrations.

Restricted access to in-person services significantly worsened behaivour and development in children with DDs due to a loss of stability, and predictability, negatively affected the function of the family unit [35,47, 28,46,48,16,50,49]. Children with DDs experienced drastically altered routines, leading to increase their anxiety, frustration, tension, aggression and rigidity [44,47,50]. Some children with autism and other neurodevelopmental disorder struggled to comply with certain public health measures, some children with sensory disorders were sensitive to the touch and smell of masks and hand sanitizers caused parents anxiety [47,54,55]. Additionally, some autistic children displayed greater physically aggression and volatility [44,16,59], further escalating parental stress and frustration. These challenges heightened emotional strains and behavioural difficulties for parents, who often reported feeling frustrated, exhausted, overwhelmed, and even aggressive, which sometimes led to harsh parenting practices [50,49]. The increased demands of addressing their children’s emotional and academic needs contributed to an authoritarian parenting style, escalated family tensions, and even violent behaviours within some households [47,50]. 

Limited access to resources, services, and various forms of support. 

In March and April 2020, Canada shut down schools and daycare centers as part of measure to prevent the spread of Covid-19, leading to a significant disruption in the educational system [47,15,55]. Parents reported receiving insufficient support from government. They faced a lack of external resources, such as programs for youth and children, closed schools and community services, limited access to healthcare facilities and treatment centres, lack of therapeutic supports in the schools, delayed therapeutic services or shifting health services to virtual mode, and extension of wait-lists for early intervention programs and reduced access to essential therapy hours (e.g., speech and language therapy, behavioural therapy, and occupational therapy) critical for their children [1,44,45,35,47,28,29,46,16,55,53,54]Parents also reported the challenges related to the absence of in-person assessment tools necessary for diagnosing children with specific needs [46,33]. The reliance on telehealth posed significant obstacles, preventing children and families from receiving the care they needed due to concerns about the COVID-19 infection, and difficulties accessing appropriate interventions [15,16, 49,51] Additionally, families required internal resources such as user skills, reliable internet connections, effective coping strategies to adapt to these new pressures. Furthermore, one recent research [46] indicated that low-income families and single parent of children with disabilities decreased likelihood of receiving services.

Parents of children with DDs experienced social and economic marginalization during the pandemic COVID-19 [28]. Caregivers reported insufficient medical support [47], limited social networks, and activities [47], increased financial insecurity [28,16], and interruptions to financial assistance, making it challenging to secure funding [28]. They also faced a lack of connection with family and friends, as well as insufficient dedicated support for parents [45,51]. These factors were compounded by job losses and reduced income, further exacerbating the stress and challenges faced by these families. 

Experiences of mental health problems

Parents caring for children with DDs during the COVID-19 pandemic have experienced significant deficits and delays in various areas of development, as well as unique additional strains. These include low mood (e.g., depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation, and distress), and other mental health-related symptoms such as frustration, increased vulnerability, isolation, sense of loss, anger, fears, exhaustion, burnout, shame, and guilt over difficulties managing their children’s behaviour. Other challenges include cultural stigma and discrimination, concerns about children’s online safety, mood disturbance, and a perceived failure in fulfilling their parental role. Parental anxiety related to job loss, economic uncertainty further heightened their vulnerability and negatively affected their well-being [44,45,35,47,28,29,15,6,46,15,51,52, 54,81,83,84]. Furthermore, parents exhibited lower levels of resilient coping [29]. Limited access to wellness services exacerbated these challenges, significantly impacting the mental health of both parents and their children with DDs [55].

Experiences of social isolation and reduced self-efficacy. 

The COVID-19 pandemic has presented unique challenges for families and caregivers of children with DDs. Both parents and children identified lack of socialization, limited social engagement, restricted access to spaces for physical activities and increased social isolation as significant challenges. These issues were compounded by increased screen time and reliance on electronic devices [1,44,45,35,47,28,48,49,52,51,53]. Prolonged home isolation has been linked to potential long-term negative consequences for the psychological wellbeing of both children and caregivers. Parents reported difficulties adhering to public health measures, which contributed to isolation and elevated stress levels4 [35, 28,16,54]. A recent study focusing on Canadian fathers of children between the ages of six and 12 with autism spectrum disorder experienced social isolation, neglected their children’s needs, and highlighted a negative perception of their self-efficacy and lack of social support for fathers [51].

Coping strategies for parents of children with DDs under COVID-19 Fostering family-teacher partnerships and providing psychological interventions are essential. 

Parents often reach out to schools and teachers for receiving additional support and services. Through these interactions, parents can become more familiar with school policies regarding children with special needs. Schools can play a critical role by offering essential resources such as daily necessities, educational services, rehabilitation programs within the school settings. Additionally, schools can provide basic food and welfare support for children with developmental disabilities and families [1,21,48]. Access to psychological interventions should also be prioritized to help alleviate mental health challenges faced by parents with developmental disabilities [48].

Creating a structured daily schedule. 

Creating a structured daily schedule has been an effective strategy for parents and caregivers helped children with DDs. They implemented various methods to help their families cope with stressors, such as organizing leisure activities, engaging in media entertainment, and exploring hobbies like baking, gardening, painting, meditation, and so on. Parents also incorporated physical activities and exercises into their routines [1,44,28,16,51] stories daily, shows, videos games, and enhancing quality family time through reinforcement system for establishing appropriate behaviours during the challengeable pandemic [44,56,51,54]

Providing resources and services and utilizing new technologies to provide support. 

The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated the use of technology to offer a broader range of care options and better address the diverse needs of children with DDs and their parents or caregivers, who often experienced heightened anxiety and frustration [1,47,28]. It is crucial for parents to maintain and strengthen social relationships while supporting their children’ mental health, and social connections. For instance, families spent more time together, and parents arranged online interactions with relatives to foster social engagement [1,16,17]. Financial resources provided to families played a vital role in facilitating access to in-home and community-based services, programs, and interventions [17,53,21, 50,82,83]. Support from extended family and community or organizations also proved invaluable [1,15,52]. Additionally, telehealth has emerged as an effective tool for education and therapy within autism communities. It can help address long waitlists for assessment and care, improve access to services in remote locations, and accommodate restricted service hours. However, parents and their children with DDs require adequate support to enhance accessibility and fully maximize its benefits [1,16,52]. 

Promoting self-efficacy and resilience

Parents who foster self-efficacy and resilience can help reduce children’s negative emotional responses [1,16,51,52,74,77,82]. Building resilience involves adopting strategies such as problem-focused coping, maintaining optimism and hope, fostering a sense of control, enhancing self-efficacy and acceptance. It also includes developing a sense of coherence, promoting positive family functioning, and enhancing care and psychosocial supports to mitigate the effects of prolonged isolation on children [1,48,51,74, 77]. 

Ensuing access to protective measures 

Parents trained their children with DDs to properly use preventative measures such as wearing masks, practicing social distancing, and self-isolating when necessary, and safely using hand sanitizer [1,16,9]. Parents reported that children with intellectual developmental delay highlighted the need for robust public health measures to mitigate the risk of transmission [52].

Discussions

The findings revealed that the COVID-19 pandemic had a significant impact on parents and their children with developmental disabilities (DDs). Globally, both groups faced substantial challenges during this period, making them particularly vulnerable. Thematic analyses of parental stressors highlighted disruptions to children’s daily routines, concerns about the closures of schools, daycares, and social services [1,47,28,29,48,54,55,72,78,79,81], which aligned with recent studies [52,57;56;57]. Many parents had to adjust their work schedules to care for their children due to these closures [54] while also experiencing increased workloads from juggling multiple family roles [1,45,16]. The shutdown of schools and services deprived children of accessing the essential programs and resources, exacerbating parental stress [58,9,33,52,55]. Similarly to the findings of [6], parents also struggled with supporting their children’s transition to online learning, which added to the challenges of remote learning [1,44,45,56,80].

Parental stress during pandemic included drastically disturbed the routines of children with DDs, leading to increased stress, anxiety, aggression and behavioural issues in children, which heightened parental concerns [44,35,47,28,29,48,16,50,49,78], which was consistent with the studies by [59,60,17]; [50] reported many parents experienced reduced patience, and increased scolding and yelling at their children during COVID-19, which was consistent with the previous studies [61,62]. Moreover, parental stressors compassed concerns about their children’s health, mental health and well-being. A study [63,84] showed individuals with Down syndrome experienced a higher susceptibility to COVID-19 infection and more severe diseases, as some parents experienced depression, anxiety and psychological distress, consistent with findings from some recent studies [16,61,64,65]. Parents expressed significant concerns about their children’s socialization, lack of social networks and activities, excessive screen time and social isolation [1,44,35,47,48,51,72, 75,78,79,81,84], alongside financial difficulties and burdens [28,49,55], and limited access to educational resources and support services [45,47,15,51], especially low income families, and single parent have decreased likelihood of receiving services [46]. These challenges were consistent with findings from [66], and [6]. 

Parents and caregivers with DDs sought support from schools and teachers to access effective academic assistance for their children, as noted by [1,44,35,52,53]. In particular, parents played a vital role in supporting their children’s online learning [80]. They also reached out to various services, including educational, recreational, community-based programs, counselling interventions, telehealth, and rehabilitation services, to help improve their children’s emotional, social and behavioural adjustments during the COVID-19 pandemic [1,44,16,52,21, 74,77]. These efforts were necessitated by quarantine measures such as social distancing, lockdowns, and the closure or suspension of health and social services, schools, and daycares, which created unprecedented challenges for raising children with DDs [1,44,48,49,53], these aligned with some recent studies [6,58,57,65,67,21,56,32, 73]. 

Some parents created structured daily schedules to provide needed routines for their children with DDs, including physical activities and exercises, leisure activities to maintain children’s social connections with their friend and relatives [1,44,16,76], these findings were aligned with studies [19,9]. Additionally, parents implemented various effective coping strategies, such as reinforcement techniques, to enhance their children’ s social and behavioural skills and improve emotional regulation [56,54]. 

The results revealed that parents provided various forms of support, including financial assistance, verbal and non-verbal information, advice, tangible aid, emotional, and instrumental support. These supports significantly benefited both parents’ and children’s mental health and well-being. This finding aligns with previous studies [41,42], which showed that social support could mitigate stressors and enhance mental health and well-being in families with DDs before pandemic. Additionally, a prior study found that parents who received psychiatric help experienced lower levels of anxiety and employed more coping strategies, such as seeking support [68]. 

This systematic review, however, had some limitations. For instance, the electronic database searches were restricted to peer-reviewed academic articles and graduate school theses with full text available from 2020 to 2024, excluding gray literatures. The review was also limited to studies published in English, thereby excluding potentially relevant research in other languages. Moreover, the review did not focus on assessing the quality of the selected articles, as highlighted by [69]. Future study should prioritize quality assessments and emphasize robust methodological designs and practical implications [70,71]. To support the mental health and well-being of these parents, and caregivers, it is crucial to develop more supportive healthcare, social educational services, and community-based interventions, and in-home activities tailored for children with developmental disabilities.

Conclusion

This systematic review provided a comprehensive overview of the challenges and stressors faced by parents and caregivers of children with developmental disabilities (DDs) during the COVID-19 pandemic. It also highlights the effective coping strategies they implemented to navigate these difficulties. The findings underscore a significant increase in parental stress during the pandemic, emphasizing the urgent need for targeted attention and resilience-building initiatives. Enhanced mental health resources and support system for parents and caregivers are essential. Greater social support from family, friends, schools, and the broader community is critical to helping parents of children with DDs lead more balanced and adaptable lives during or after pandemic. Public health interventions should prioritize addressing parenting-specific stressors, developing context-specific policies and programs to support these families, and promoting effective coping strategies. These measures should consider the unique needs of these families raising children with DDs to mitigate the long-term impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic.

References

Clearly Auctoresonline and particularly Psychology and Mental Health Care Journal is dedicated to improving health care services for individuals and populations. The editorial boards' ability to efficiently recognize and share the global importance of health literacy with a variety of stakeholders. Auctoresonline publishing platform can be used to facilitate of optimal client-based services and should be added to health care professionals' repertoire of evidence-based health care resources.

img

Virginia E. Koenig

Journal of Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Intervention The submission and review process was adequate. However I think that the publication total value should have been enlightened in early fases. Thank you for all.

img

Delcio G Silva Junior

Journal of Women Health Care and Issues By the present mail, I want to say thank to you and tour colleagues for facilitating my published article. Specially thank you for the peer review process, support from the editorial office. I appreciate positively the quality of your journal.

img

Ziemlé Clément Méda

Journal of Clinical Research and Reports I would be very delighted to submit my testimonial regarding the reviewer board and the editorial office. The reviewer board were accurate and helpful regarding any modifications for my manuscript. And the editorial office were very helpful and supportive in contacting and monitoring with any update and offering help. It was my pleasure to contribute with your promising Journal and I am looking forward for more collaboration.

img

Mina Sherif Soliman Georgy

We would like to thank the Journal of Thoracic Disease and Cardiothoracic Surgery because of the services they provided us for our articles. The peer-review process was done in a very excellent time manner, and the opinions of the reviewers helped us to improve our manuscript further. The editorial office had an outstanding correspondence with us and guided us in many ways. During a hard time of the pandemic that is affecting every one of us tremendously, the editorial office helped us make everything easier for publishing scientific work. Hope for a more scientific relationship with your Journal.

img

Layla Shojaie

The peer-review process which consisted high quality queries on the paper. I did answer six reviewers’ questions and comments before the paper was accepted. The support from the editorial office is excellent.

img

Sing-yung Wu

Journal of Neuroscience and Neurological Surgery. I had the experience of publishing a research article recently. The whole process was simple from submission to publication. The reviewers made specific and valuable recommendations and corrections that improved the quality of my publication. I strongly recommend this Journal.

img

Orlando Villarreal

Dr. Katarzyna Byczkowska My testimonial covering: "The peer review process is quick and effective. The support from the editorial office is very professional and friendly. Quality of the Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Interventions is scientific and publishes ground-breaking research on cardiology that is useful for other professionals in the field.

img

Katarzyna Byczkowska

Thank you most sincerely, with regard to the support you have given in relation to the reviewing process and the processing of my article entitled "Large Cell Neuroendocrine Carcinoma of The Prostate Gland: A Review and Update" for publication in your esteemed Journal, Journal of Cancer Research and Cellular Therapeutics". The editorial team has been very supportive.

img

Anthony Kodzo-Grey Venyo

Testimony of Journal of Clinical Otorhinolaryngology: work with your Reviews has been a educational and constructive experience. The editorial office were very helpful and supportive. It was a pleasure to contribute to your Journal.

img

Pedro Marques Gomes

Dr. Bernard Terkimbi Utoo, I am happy to publish my scientific work in Journal of Women Health Care and Issues (JWHCI). The manuscript submission was seamless and peer review process was top notch. I was amazed that 4 reviewers worked on the manuscript which made it a highly technical, standard and excellent quality paper. I appreciate the format and consideration for the APC as well as the speed of publication. It is my pleasure to continue with this scientific relationship with the esteem JWHCI.

img

Bernard Terkimbi Utoo

This is an acknowledgment for peer reviewers, editorial board of Journal of Clinical Research and Reports. They show a lot of consideration for us as publishers for our research article “Evaluation of the different factors associated with side effects of COVID-19 vaccination on medical students, Mutah university, Al-Karak, Jordan”, in a very professional and easy way. This journal is one of outstanding medical journal.

img

Prof Sherif W Mansour

Dear Hao Jiang, to Journal of Nutrition and Food Processing We greatly appreciate the efficient, professional and rapid processing of our paper by your team. If there is anything else we should do, please do not hesitate to let us know. On behalf of my co-authors, we would like to express our great appreciation to editor and reviewers.

img

Hao Jiang

As an author who has recently published in the journal "Brain and Neurological Disorders". I am delighted to provide a testimonial on the peer review process, editorial office support, and the overall quality of the journal. The peer review process at Brain and Neurological Disorders is rigorous and meticulous, ensuring that only high-quality, evidence-based research is published. The reviewers are experts in their fields, and their comments and suggestions were constructive and helped improve the quality of my manuscript. The review process was timely and efficient, with clear communication from the editorial office at each stage. The support from the editorial office was exceptional throughout the entire process. The editorial staff was responsive, professional, and always willing to help. They provided valuable guidance on formatting, structure, and ethical considerations, making the submission process seamless. Moreover, they kept me informed about the status of my manuscript and provided timely updates, which made the process less stressful. The journal Brain and Neurological Disorders is of the highest quality, with a strong focus on publishing cutting-edge research in the field of neurology. The articles published in this journal are well-researched, rigorously peer-reviewed, and written by experts in the field. The journal maintains high standards, ensuring that readers are provided with the most up-to-date and reliable information on brain and neurological disorders. In conclusion, I had a wonderful experience publishing in Brain and Neurological Disorders. The peer review process was thorough, the editorial office provided exceptional support, and the journal's quality is second to none. I would highly recommend this journal to any researcher working in the field of neurology and brain disorders.

img

Dr Shiming Tang

Dear Agrippa Hilda, Journal of Neuroscience and Neurological Surgery, Editorial Coordinator, I trust this message finds you well. I want to extend my appreciation for considering my article for publication in your esteemed journal. I am pleased to provide a testimonial regarding the peer review process and the support received from your editorial office. The peer review process for my paper was carried out in a highly professional and thorough manner. The feedback and comments provided by the authors were constructive and very useful in improving the quality of the manuscript. This rigorous assessment process undoubtedly contributes to the high standards maintained by your journal.

img

Raed Mualem

International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews. I strongly recommend to consider submitting your work to this high-quality journal. The support and availability of the Editorial staff is outstanding and the review process was both efficient and rigorous.

img

Andreas Filippaios

Thank you very much for publishing my Research Article titled “Comparing Treatment Outcome Of Allergic Rhinitis Patients After Using Fluticasone Nasal Spray And Nasal Douching" in the Journal of Clinical Otorhinolaryngology. As Medical Professionals we are immensely benefited from study of various informative Articles and Papers published in this high quality Journal. I look forward to enriching my knowledge by regular study of the Journal and contribute my future work in the field of ENT through the Journal for use by the medical fraternity. The support from the Editorial office was excellent and very prompt. I also welcome the comments received from the readers of my Research Article.

img

Dr Suramya Dhamija

Dear Erica Kelsey, Editorial Coordinator of Cancer Research and Cellular Therapeutics Our team is very satisfied with the processing of our paper by your journal. That was fast, efficient, rigorous, but without unnecessary complications. We appreciated the very short time between the submission of the paper and its publication on line on your site.

img

Bruno Chauffert

I am very glad to say that the peer review process is very successful and fast and support from the Editorial Office. Therefore, I would like to continue our scientific relationship for a long time. And I especially thank you for your kindly attention towards my article. Have a good day!

img

Baheci Selen

"We recently published an article entitled “Influence of beta-Cyclodextrins upon the Degradation of Carbofuran Derivatives under Alkaline Conditions" in the Journal of “Pesticides and Biofertilizers” to show that the cyclodextrins protect the carbamates increasing their half-life time in the presence of basic conditions This will be very helpful to understand carbofuran behaviour in the analytical, agro-environmental and food areas. We greatly appreciated the interaction with the editor and the editorial team; we were particularly well accompanied during the course of the revision process, since all various steps towards publication were short and without delay".

img

Jesus Simal-Gandara

I would like to express my gratitude towards you process of article review and submission. I found this to be very fair and expedient. Your follow up has been excellent. I have many publications in national and international journal and your process has been one of the best so far. Keep up the great work.

img

Douglas Miyazaki

We are grateful for this opportunity to provide a glowing recommendation to the Journal of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy. We found that the editorial team were very supportive, helpful, kept us abreast of timelines and over all very professional in nature. The peer review process was rigorous, efficient and constructive that really enhanced our article submission. The experience with this journal remains one of our best ever and we look forward to providing future submissions in the near future.

img

Dr Griffith

I am very pleased to serve as EBM of the journal, I hope many years of my experience in stem cells can help the journal from one way or another. As we know, stem cells hold great potential for regenerative medicine, which are mostly used to promote the repair response of diseased, dysfunctional or injured tissue using stem cells or their derivatives. I think Stem Cell Research and Therapeutics International is a great platform to publish and share the understanding towards the biology and translational or clinical application of stem cells.

img

Dr Tong Ming Liu

I would like to give my testimony in the support I have got by the peer review process and to support the editorial office where they were of asset to support young author like me to be encouraged to publish their work in your respected journal and globalize and share knowledge across the globe. I really give my great gratitude to your journal and the peer review including the editorial office.

img

Husain Taha Radhi

I am delighted to publish our manuscript entitled "A Perspective on Cocaine Induced Stroke - Its Mechanisms and Management" in the Journal of Neuroscience and Neurological Surgery. The peer review process, support from the editorial office, and quality of the journal are excellent. The manuscripts published are of high quality and of excellent scientific value. I recommend this journal very much to colleagues.

img

S Munshi

Dr.Tania Muñoz, My experience as researcher and author of a review article in The Journal Clinical Cardiology and Interventions has been very enriching and stimulating. The editorial team is excellent, performs its work with absolute responsibility and delivery. They are proactive, dynamic and receptive to all proposals. Supporting at all times the vast universe of authors who choose them as an option for publication. The team of review specialists, members of the editorial board, are brilliant professionals, with remarkable performance in medical research and scientific methodology. Together they form a frontline team that consolidates the JCCI as a magnificent option for the publication and review of high-level medical articles and broad collective interest. I am honored to be able to share my review article and open to receive all your comments.

img

Tania Munoz

“The peer review process of JPMHC is quick and effective. Authors are benefited by good and professional reviewers with huge experience in the field of psychology and mental health. The support from the editorial office is very professional. People to contact to are friendly and happy to help and assist any query authors might have. Quality of the Journal is scientific and publishes ground-breaking research on mental health that is useful for other professionals in the field”.

img

George Varvatsoulias

Dear editorial department: On behalf of our team, I hereby certify the reliability and superiority of the International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews in the peer review process, editorial support, and journal quality. Firstly, the peer review process of the International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews is rigorous, fair, transparent, fast, and of high quality. The editorial department invites experts from relevant fields as anonymous reviewers to review all submitted manuscripts. These experts have rich academic backgrounds and experience, and can accurately evaluate the academic quality, originality, and suitability of manuscripts. The editorial department is committed to ensuring the rigor of the peer review process, while also making every effort to ensure a fast review cycle to meet the needs of authors and the academic community. Secondly, the editorial team of the International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews is composed of a group of senior scholars and professionals with rich experience and professional knowledge in related fields. The editorial department is committed to assisting authors in improving their manuscripts, ensuring their academic accuracy, clarity, and completeness. Editors actively collaborate with authors, providing useful suggestions and feedback to promote the improvement and development of the manuscript. We believe that the support of the editorial department is one of the key factors in ensuring the quality of the journal. Finally, the International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews is renowned for its high- quality articles and strict academic standards. The editorial department is committed to publishing innovative and academically valuable research results to promote the development and progress of related fields. The International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews is reasonably priced and ensures excellent service and quality ratio, allowing authors to obtain high-level academic publishing opportunities in an affordable manner. I hereby solemnly declare that the International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews has a high level of credibility and superiority in terms of peer review process, editorial support, reasonable fees, and journal quality. Sincerely, Rui Tao.

img

Rui Tao

Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Interventions I testity the covering of the peer review process, support from the editorial office, and quality of the journal.

img

Khurram Arshad

Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Interventions, we deeply appreciate the interest shown in our work and its publication. It has been a true pleasure to collaborate with you. The peer review process, as well as the support provided by the editorial office, have been exceptional, and the quality of the journal is very high, which was a determining factor in our decision to publish with you.

img

Gomez Barriga Maria Dolores

The peer reviewers process is quick and effective, the supports from editorial office is excellent, the quality of journal is high. I would like to collabroate with Internatioanl journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews journal clinically in the future time.

img

Lin Shaw Chin

Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Interventions, I would like to express my sincerest gratitude for the trust placed in our team for the publication in your journal. It has been a true pleasure to collaborate with you on this project. I am pleased to inform you that both the peer review process and the attention from the editorial coordination have been excellent. Your team has worked with dedication and professionalism to ensure that your publication meets the highest standards of quality. We are confident that this collaboration will result in mutual success, and we are eager to see the fruits of this shared effort.

img

Maria Dolores Gomez Barriga

Dear Dr. Jessica Magne, Editorial Coordinator 0f Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Interventions, I hope this message finds you well. I want to express my utmost gratitude for your excellent work and for the dedication and speed in the publication process of my article titled "Navigating Innovation: Qualitative Insights on Using Technology for Health Education in Acute Coronary Syndrome Patients." I am very satisfied with the peer review process, the support from the editorial office, and the quality of the journal. I hope we can maintain our scientific relationship in the long term.

img

Dr Maria Dolores Gomez Barriga

Dear Monica Gissare, - Editorial Coordinator of Nutrition and Food Processing. ¨My testimony with you is truly professional, with a positive response regarding the follow-up of the article and its review, you took into account my qualities and the importance of the topic¨.

img

Dr Maria Regina Penchyna Nieto

Dear Dr. Jessica Magne, Editorial Coordinator 0f Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Interventions, The review process for the article “The Handling of Anti-aggregants and Anticoagulants in the Oncologic Heart Patient Submitted to Surgery” was extremely rigorous and detailed. From the initial submission to the final acceptance, the editorial team at the “Journal of Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Interventions” demonstrated a high level of professionalism and dedication. The reviewers provided constructive and detailed feedback, which was essential for improving the quality of our work. Communication was always clear and efficient, ensuring that all our questions were promptly addressed. The quality of the “Journal of Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Interventions” is undeniable. It is a peer-reviewed, open-access publication dedicated exclusively to disseminating high-quality research in the field of clinical cardiology and cardiovascular interventions. The journal's impact factor is currently under evaluation, and it is indexed in reputable databases, which further reinforces its credibility and relevance in the scientific field. I highly recommend this journal to researchers looking for a reputable platform to publish their studies.

img

Dr Marcelo Flavio Gomes Jardim Filho

Dear Editorial Coordinator of the Journal of Nutrition and Food Processing! "I would like to thank the Journal of Nutrition and Food Processing for including and publishing my article. The peer review process was very quick, movement and precise. The Editorial Board has done an extremely conscientious job with much help, valuable comments and advices. I find the journal very valuable from a professional point of view, thank you very much for allowing me to be part of it and I would like to participate in the future!”

img

Zsuzsanna Bene

Dealing with The Journal of Neurology and Neurological Surgery was very smooth and comprehensive. The office staff took time to address my needs and the response from editors and the office was prompt and fair. I certainly hope to publish with this journal again.Their professionalism is apparent and more than satisfactory. Susan Weiner

img

Dr Susan Weiner

My Testimonial Covering as fellowing: Lin-Show Chin. The peer reviewers process is quick and effective, the supports from editorial office is excellent, the quality of journal is high. I would like to collabroate with Internatioanl journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews.

img

Lin-Show Chin

My experience publishing in Psychology and Mental Health Care was exceptional. The peer review process was rigorous and constructive, with reviewers providing valuable insights that helped enhance the quality of our work. The editorial team was highly supportive and responsive, making the submission process smooth and efficient. The journal's commitment to high standards and academic rigor makes it a respected platform for quality research. I am grateful for the opportunity to publish in such a reputable journal.

img

Sonila Qirko

My experience publishing in International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews was exceptional. I Come forth to Provide a Testimonial Covering the Peer Review Process and the editorial office for the Professional and Impartial Evaluation of the Manuscript.

img

Luiz Sellmann

I would like to offer my testimony in the support. I have received through the peer review process and support the editorial office where they are to support young authors like me, encourage them to publish their work in your esteemed journals, and globalize and share knowledge globally. I really appreciate your journal, peer review, and editorial office.

img

Zhao Jia

Dear Agrippa Hilda- Editorial Coordinator of Journal of Neuroscience and Neurological Surgery, "The peer review process was very quick and of high quality, which can also be seen in the articles in the journal. The collaboration with the editorial office was very good."

img

Thomas Urban

I would like to express my sincere gratitude for the support and efficiency provided by the editorial office throughout the publication process of my article, “Delayed Vulvar Metastases from Rectal Carcinoma: A Case Report.” I greatly appreciate the assistance and guidance I received from your team, which made the entire process smooth and efficient. The peer review process was thorough and constructive, contributing to the overall quality of the final article. I am very grateful for the high level of professionalism and commitment shown by the editorial staff, and I look forward to maintaining a long-term collaboration with the International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews.

img

Cristina Berriozabal

To Dear Erin Aust, I would like to express my heartfelt appreciation for the opportunity to have my work published in this esteemed journal. The entire publication process was smooth and well-organized, and I am extremely satisfied with the final result. The Editorial Team demonstrated the utmost professionalism, providing prompt and insightful feedback throughout the review process. Their clear communication and constructive suggestions were invaluable in enhancing my manuscript, and their meticulous attention to detail and dedication to quality are truly commendable. Additionally, the support from the Editorial Office was exceptional. From the initial submission to the final publication, I was guided through every step of the process with great care and professionalism. The team's responsiveness and assistance made the entire experience both easy and stress-free. I am also deeply impressed by the quality and reputation of the journal. It is an honor to have my research featured in such a respected publication, and I am confident that it will make a meaningful contribution to the field.

img

Dr Tewodros Kassahun Tarekegn

"I am grateful for the opportunity of contributing to [International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews] and for the rigorous review process that enhances the quality of research published in your esteemed journal. I sincerely appreciate the time and effort of your team who have dedicatedly helped me in improvising changes and modifying my manuscript. The insightful comments and constructive feedback provided have been invaluable in refining and strengthening my work".

img

Dr Shweta Tiwari

I thank the ‘Journal of Clinical Research and Reports’ for accepting this article for publication. This is a rigorously peer reviewed journal which is on all major global scientific data bases. I note the review process was prompt, thorough and professionally critical. It gave us an insight into a number of important scientific/statistical issues. The review prompted us to review the relevant literature again and look at the limitations of the study. The peer reviewers were open, clear in the instructions and the editorial team was very prompt in their communication. This journal certainly publishes quality research articles. I would recommend the journal for any future publications.

img

Dr Farooq Wandroo

Dear Jessica Magne, with gratitude for the joint work. Fast process of receiving and processing the submitted scientific materials in “Clinical Cardiology and Cardiovascular Interventions”. High level of competence of the editors with clear and correct recommendations and ideas for enriching the article.

img

Dr Anyuta Ivanova

We found the peer review process quick and positive in its input. The support from the editorial officer has been very agile, always with the intention of improving the article and taking into account our subsequent corrections.

img

Dr David Vinyes